Question:

Could you explain the concepts of “absolute justice” and “relative justice”? Based on the notion of relative justice, is it permissible to disregard individual rights for the benefit of the state or an institution?

Answer:

At its most fundamental level, justice signifies balance and uprightness; living one’s life upon the straight path. Preserving this is essential both to individual and social life and to the continued existence of nations. Justice also signifies the perfection of one’s servitude to God and the ordering of one’s life according to divine principles. Consequently, justice is far more than a legal concept. To regard it merely as a matter of social order is to understand it only partially. Justice is also closely connected with a person’s inner world, faith, and life of worship. In other words, acting with genuine justice depends on sincerely putting one’s religious convictions into practice. Indeed, when Bediuzzaman Said Nursi identifies the Qur’an’s fundamental objectives, he lists justice immediately after the oneness of God (tawhid), prophethood, and resurrection. In doing so, he emphasizes that justice is indispensable to the complete and proper practice of religion [1].

Although traces of the distinction between absolute justice (adalet-i mahza) and relative justice (adalet-i izafiye) can be found within the broader Islamic intellectual tradition, it was Bediuzzaman who articulated these two concepts clearly and systematically [2].

Absolute justice does not permit the violation of even one innocent person’s rights, regardless of the public benefit at stake. According to this understanding, an individual’s rights cannot be disregarded for the sake of the nation or the wider community. Relative justice, by contrast, allows a lesser harm to be accepted to prevent a greater one. It is based on the principle of choosing the lesser of two evils. Absolute justice may therefore be described as a rights-based approach, whereas relative justice is primarily guided by considerations of the public good (maslaha).

The risk of abuse in relative justice

Those in positions of leadership and governance are obliged to uphold absolute justice as far as possible, for it represents the highest ideal. Believers should always strive to meet the highest standard in matters of religion. Nevertheless, circumstances may arise in which absolute justice cannot be fully applied. Widespread crises or extraordinary situations (balvâ-yı âmm) may make certain concessions necessary. In some cases, the strict application of absolute justice may not be sufficient to preserve public order and social stability. Under these exceptional circumstances, it may be necessary to turn to relative justice.

Because relative justice is invoked on the grounds of necessity (zarura) and the public good (maslaha), it rests on an extremely delicate foundation. The claim that a greater harm is being prevented can easily become subject to arbitrary interpretation, thereby allowing those in positions of power to legitimize their own decisions and actions. For this reason, it must be determined with the utmost care whether a genuine necessity exists, whether all reasonable alternatives have been exhausted, and whether the harm being accepted is truly the lesser of the available evils. Otherwise, relative justice may cease to be a principle that protects rights and instead become a means of concealing injustice. Indeed, history provides examples in which the rights of certain individuals were violated under the banner of preserving the “eternal state” (devlet-i ebed müddet). Likewise, even in the most democratic societies, serious injustices have sometimes been committed in the name of the public interest.

Relative justice carries another risk. In Islamic law, public rights are also regarded as the rights of God (huquq Allah), which underscores their profound importance. When responding to certain events, people may therefore invoke relative justice to disregard individual rights in favor of public rights. Over time, individual rights may increasingly be treated as insignificant and no longer adequately protected. As a result, people may be deemed guilty and subjected to severe punishments based on speculation or unfounded claims.

The limits of freedom

One further point requires clarification. According to the principle of absolute justice, no individual’s rights should be violated, even when the rights of the wider community are at stake. This, however, does not mean that everyone is free to act as they please or that they cannot be held accountable for their actions. Respect for individual rights and freedom of conscience does not entail granting people unlimited freedom. An individual’s rights extend only to the point at which the rights of others begin. If the exercise of individual rights harms the rights of the wider community, certain legal sanctions inevitably become necessary. Even the most liberal legal systems recognize that rights and freedoms are subject to reasonable limitations. For example, individuals are not permitted to incite social discord or public disorder with impunity. When actions threaten public safety or infringe upon the rights of others, lawful restrictions may be necessary, as illustrated by responses to armed rebellion during the lifetimes of Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) and the four Rightly Guided Caliphs who succeeded him.

Whether a citizen of a state or a member of a civil organization, if a person’s actions undermine social cohesion or infringe upon the rights of the wider community, society has a responsibility to prevent such conduct. There are, however, different ways of fulfilling this responsibility. The first step is to offer sincere advice and seek to persuade the individual to abandon the harmful course of action. If the person persists, other measures may be taken to prevent further harm. Where necessary, the individual may be isolated from a particular group or removed from that environment. If a legal offense has been committed, the law should be applied to prevent further harm. Depending on the nature of the harm caused, appropriate remedies may include a retraction, clarification, correction, or compensation.

The principle is much like that of passengers travelling aboard the same ship: no one can be allowed to bore a hole in the vessel, for if the ship sinks, everyone on board will suffer. Preventing such an act—and taking away the tool being used to damage the ship—is therefore both the right and the responsibility of everyone aboard.

Law and consultation as safeguards against arbitrariness

To prevent abuse, such matters must not be left to personal opinion or entrusted to the discretion of particular individuals, where desires and prejudices may influence decisions. Solutions must always be sought within the framework of the law. Offenses should be clearly defined in advance, and those who commit them should be held accountable through due legal process. As Bediuzzaman emphasizes, authority must reside in the law, not in individuals [3].

The same principle applies to social organizations such as charitable foundations, associations, and religious communities. Decisions about when and how to apply absolute or relative justice should be made through established processes of consultation (shura), rather than arbitrary individual judgment. Organizations should consult their governing bodies when exercising their authority and act in accordance with established bylaws and regulations.

The foundation of justice: Faith and conscience

Establishing justice depends largely on faith, one’s relationship with God, and a deep sense of moral responsibility. Some individuals hold broad discretionary authority, and their decisions may profoundly affect many lives. Those with a strong relationship with God, who believe that harming even the smallest creature carries grave moral responsibility, will not lightly violate others’ rights or knowingly commit injustice. By contrast, those whose belief in the Hereafter is weak and who have little fear of ultimate accountability may become captive to their personal desires, make unjust decisions, and engage in wrongful practices. They may even use religious arguments to justify their negligence, mistakes, and oppression.

People whose hearts are filled with reverence for God do not wish to stand before Him burdened by violations of others’ rights. They examine their shortcomings and weigh their actions on the delicate scales of conscience, carefully considering whether they uphold justice or infringe upon another person’s rights. Their aim is to uphold truth and achieve absolute justice. If circumstances leave them no choice but to turn to relative justice, they do so with a profound sense of moral responsibility. If they realize they have violated someone’s rights, even unintentionally, they do not hesitate to repair the injustice, apologize, and seek forgiveness.

When faith and taqwa (God-consciousness) are weak, people may rationalize oppression and present it as justice. They reshape justice according to their preferences, expanding or restricting its boundaries to suit themselves. Religion, however, was revealed to shape human beings according to truth and justice, not for people to reshape it according to their desires. Religion belongs to God; our duty is to remain faithful to the principles and limits He has established.

If we feel constrained while striving to follow religious teachings, the problem lies not in religion itself but in our approach to it. Our society, culture, or upbringing may have instilled mistaken habits or assumptions in us. Our first priority should therefore be to reform ourselves and overcome these shortcomings. As we develop the moral and spiritual maturity needed to practice religion fully, we become better able to uphold justice and respect the rights of all.

References

[1] See Bediüzzaman, İşârâtü’l-İ’câz, p. 9; Muhâkemât, p. 9; Barla Lâhikası, p. 309.

[2] Bediüzzaman, Mektubat, pp. 54–55 (“The Fifteenth Letter,” “The Second Question”).

[3] Bediüzzaman, Tarihçe-i Hayat, p. 54.